This week we had our virtual replacement for the colour print competition. Members submitted the images they would have used as colour prints digitally. The competition was judged by Fiona Brims of Stirling and District Camera Club. You can see some of Fiona’s work at the link below.
Fiona was unable to join us by Zoom, so George Todd read out her comments. Fiona began with a letter telling us that judging the images had been difficult because there had been so many good entries. She had had to be pernickety in her judging to separate these images, but she explained this was just one person’s judgement. She was born in Musselburgh and was delighted to be judging for her old home town.
54 images had been entered altogether. There were landscapes, portraits, photographs of birds (which Fiona recognised by name from the World of Wings bird of prey centre) and close-ups of flowers and cacti. There were also some imaginative abstract images, some of which Fiona felt were more digital art than digital photography. Fiona commented on the composition and technical execution of each image. There were some images where a longer shutter speed could have given a more dynamic image of a moving target by adding motion blur, and there were other images of moving water where a shorter shutter speed would have prevented burn out. Some of the close-up images could have been improved by a smaller aperture and larger depth of field. Some images were let down by dust marks, noisy backgrounds or editing mistakes. Fiona didn’t like the ivory borders that some members had used and recommended that digital images should have borders no wider than 3 pixels.
The top scorers were (in reverse order):
- 5th place (46 points)
- 4th place (48 points)
- 3rd place (50 points)
- Joe Fowler
- Malcolm Roberts
- Steven Beard
- Steve Williams
- 2nd place (52 points)
- George Todd
- Mike Clark
- Anne Yeomans
- 1st place (53 points)
The top images were:
- Rattray Head at Dusk (Steve Williams) – 20 points
- Sparrowhawk (Jennifer Davidson) – 19 points
- Pool Room (Joe Fowler) – 19 points
- Hover Fly on Flower (Malcolm Roberts) – 19 points
- Brown Hare Grazing (George Todd) – 19 points
- Incoming (Mike Clark) – 19 points
- Northern Gannet (Anne Yeomans) – 18 points
The fact that the top images are spread between so many members shows the consistent quality of the entries. Well done everyone, and an especially well done to Jennifer Davidson, who wins the trophy. My apologies to Anne Yeomans, whose superb image of a gannet catching a fish in mid air would have done better without the ivory border I had provided in my earlier post.