Happy New Year! The season restarted with our annual Human Portrait Print Competition. George Robertson, who had given us these fantastic talks on mountain photography, returned to the club as judge rather than speaker.
23 September 2021 (Into the Throne Room of the Mountain Gods)
22 September 2022 (George Robertson: The Snows of Kilimanjaro)
31 October 2024 (George Robertson: Exploring Kathmandu and the Khumbu Valley)
George explained that when he judges prints he first splits them into two piles, 20 points and 17 points, based on their initial impact. He then waits a couple of days and looks again at the prints to see if any had gone into the wrong pile. Finally, he looks in more detail and subtracts points for technical issues such as sharpness, exposure or processing faults.
36 prints had been entered by 12 members. Some period portraits had been taken at Duncarron Medieval Village or at a battle re-enactment such as the battle of Prestonpans. There were also some travel portraits and studio portraits, including some of club members taken at our recent creative lighting workshop or studio night. George recognised the familiar faces. George critiqued the impact and engagement of each image, noting whether the pose, expression and composition helped or hindered the intended story. Most of the images were sharp where they needed to be (on the eyes of the subject) but some were sharper than others. The emphasis needed to be on the face, and in some images the face wasn’t the brightest area. There were also some images where dark clothing appeared to merge with a dark background. George also spotted some post-processing faults and noted that some prints had a yellow or magenta tint. He suggested using the texture tool in Adobe Lightroom to soften or roughen the face, depending on the situation (e.g. soften for a beauty shot or roughen for a battle scenario). Here is a YouTube video explaining how to do this:
YouTube video demonstrating the Adobe Lightroom “texture” tool.
George finished by revealing the top images which gave him the most impact but had fewest technical faults. He suggested we look closely into the eyes of the top image, “Beauty can be Fragile”, to see the detail and sharpness. When all the scores were added up, the top scorers were (in reverse order):
- 5th place (49 points)
- Carol Edmond
- Jennifer Davidson
- 4th place (50 points)
- Mike Clark
- 3rd place (51 points)
- Melanie Gallacher
- 2nd place (53 points)
- George Todd
- 1st place (55 points)
- Derek Muller
George’s top images were:
- Beauty can be Fragile (Derek Muller) – 20 points
- Touch of Elegance (Melanie Gallacher) – 19 points
- Soothsayer has Concerns (Derek Muller) – 19 points
- Kalon – Ink Tells My Story (George Todd) – 18 points
- Red Haired Beauty (Mike Clark) – 18 points
- Woodland Queen (Jennifer Davidson) – 18 points
Well done to Derek for winning the trophy and for producing such a magnificent top image. Well done also to George and Melanie for their consistently high quality entries. Thank you to everyone who entered and thank you to George Robertson for judging the competition and giving us some good advice.
- Please send your 3 “weather” images to George Todd as soon as possible.
- Next week we have a club where we can take the opportunity to look at the 21 images that we missed seeing at the Black and White Print Competition on 4th December. This is unlikely to take the whole evening, so if you have a photograph from the Christmas holidays that you would like to show, please bring it along and we can show it at the end (depending on how much time we have).

